Is It Time for Workplaces to Ditch Annual Performance Reviews? This CEO Thinks So
Spencer Saunders, president and CEO of Art & Science, would be the first to let you know that efficiency evaluations at his agency typically was “dreadful for everybody involved.” Before the Toronto-based digital company began overhauling its course of in 2021, it used the standard annual mannequin, the place workers sat down with managers to speak about how the yr went, and could be rated on a standardized rubric starting from “needs improvement” to “exceeds expectations.” If all went properly, an worker would possibly get a elevate or bonus. “It was a monolithic event,” says Saunders. It was time consuming and anxious for workers, he says, and raised the potential for recency bias, the place your most up-to-date work stands in for a complete yr’s efficiency, good or unhealthy.
Around the identical time, in 2021, the company was rising, and Saunders was debating whether or not to rent a human assets crew, which they company presently didn’t have. This led him to Amanda Hudson, founding father of Toronto-based HR consultancy A Modern Way To Work. Saunders employed Hudson as a guide and so they started working collectively on a holistic overhaul of how Art & Science approaches folks administration. Along with revamping compensation packages and investing in supervisor coaching, re-imagining efficiency evaluations grew to become a precedence.
Related: Would You Tell Your Boss How You Really Feel About Work? That’s the Point of ‘Stay Interviews’
Hudson began assembly with Art & Science’s senior management crew to grasp what was (and wasn’t) working for them, and what they needed out of the brand new assessment course of. Themes emerged when it got here to what was wanted: equity throughout groups so everybody has the identical alternatives; a constant method that solved for biases like favouritism; and a collaborative course of that higher concerned each managers and their studies.
They landed on a “360 approach” to efficiency administration, constructed round common one-on-one conferences, which vary from weekly to month-to-month relying on the crew, with a significant construction and objective. “You can have the small talk, but it’s more about ‘What can I help you with?’ and ‘Where do I need you to improve?’” explains Saunders. To facilitate this, they started utilizing the software program Lattice, which helps schedule these chats, after which paperwork the dialogue.
The different benefit of this software program, says Saunders, is the way in which it allows “continuous feedback,” quite than a once-a-year thought dump. This is inspired not simply from manager-to-employee, however employee-to-manager, and likewise employee-to-employee. “We’re not naming and shaming, but it’s a tool to facilitate some of this communication,” says Saunders. “It also means we’ve got a record.” This degree of documentation has meant that managers have a deeper grasp of what’s been occurring with an worker over an prolonged interval, and might higher assist them. “The employee can also ask for feedback through the system,” provides Hudson.
Related: How to Improve Your Company’s Glassdoor Rating
Conversely, if a supervisor desires to eliminate somebody for poor efficiency, senior management’s first port-of-call is that this report. They’ll look to see if the supervisor and report have been assembly commonly, and if there’s been a documented dialog concerning the challenge, or if there’s different suggestions from colleagues that echo the priority.
Alongside this steady suggestions mannequin, the Art & Science crew needed to make sure there was nonetheless a set event the place issues like promotions or raises may be formally mentioned (though these conversations can occur at any level below the brand new system). Enter “milestone meetings,” which are sometimes tied to an worker’s work anniversary. “What I love about milestone meetings is that both the employee and the manager are presented with a set of questions, so there’s an aspect of reflection,” says Saunders. These questions are particular, and the bulk are strengths-focused: When have been you most engaged this yr? What are you most pleased with? What conditions have been probably the most anxious? These questions can level out areas of alignment—worker and supervisor would possibly each agree that the worker is nice with shoppers, for instance. “If an employee is over performing, or ready for that next career step, their manager can go to Spencer and say, ‘Here’s all the feedback, all the one-on-ones to prove it. Let’s give them a promotion,’” Hudson says.
Related: Does Your Boss Make You Feel Valued? Employee Recognition Programs Can Fix That
Saunders’s work philosophy is that efficiency doesn’t at all times should be rewarded with a title change or promotion. After all, some folks don’t wish to be managers. “The value someone may be delivering is absolutely worth some kind of remuneration that should be performance-based, and still be equitable, because we can point to exactly how they’ve been crushing it or exceeding expectations,” he says. “A manager might step back and say, ‘Maybe this employee needs to be rewarded with a one-time bonus.’”
Because Art & Science’s course of is innately about elevating workers’ success, Saunders says that it has naturally led to issues like larger engagement and higher job satisfaction. The company has additionally lowered voluntary worker turnover by about 50 per cent between 2021 and 2022. Now, in exit interviews, Saunders isn’t making “frustrating discoveries” anymore, like somebody saying they hadn’t spoken to their supervisor in six months. “Even when people leave the firm, they will thank us for the time and effort in how they were managed while they were here.”
