Calgary Is Converting Abandoned Offices Into Housing
When Maxim Olshevsky stepped inside 909 fifth Ave. SW, a 10-storey constructing in downtown Calgary, he might have sworn he was trying on the aftermath of a zombie apocalypse. Frayed cubicle partitions loomed over piles of expired contracts; identify tags lay deserted on dust-blanketed desks. To most, this might be supply materials for an episode of The Last of Us; to Olshevsky, a Calgary-based actual property and development entrepreneur with a comfortable spot for bringing issues again from the lifeless, it was pure potential.
A scorching tip had led Olshevsky to the positioning in 2021; within the 4 years prior, his firm, Astra Real Estate Group, had targeted on foreclosed and condemned buildings, initiatives in want of a critical overhaul. “That became our niche,” he says. “All of a sudden, we started getting calls: ‘Hey! Wanna look at this building that’s falling apart?’”
Having established himself as a de facto fixer of fixer-uppers, Olshevsky was unfazed when he surveyed what remained of 909. The mid-rise, in-built 1979 in accordance with aesthetic specs harking back to a Buick Skylark, had been principally deserted since 2015, when SNC Lavalin rescinded its naming rights and pulled its operations; whereas two straggler tenants remained on-site, the majority of its 12,000-square-metre area was empty. But Olshevsky sensed he was standing on the bottom flooring of an modern improvement alternative.
“I thought that if this building sat here like this for almost 10 years, how many other commercial buildings in Calgary were in the same condition?” says Olshevsky. A yr into the Covid pandemic, it was clear that the hordes of staff who’d gone digital had been unlikely to return to their bricks-and-mortar house bases—not less than, not en masse. Factor in a widespread housing disaster, and the answer appeared clear: What if these deserted workplace areas might be acquired, overhauled and repurposed into residential models?
Around the identical time, Calgary’s municipal authorities was figuring out the ultimate particulars of a technique aimed toward tackling a plummeting industrial actual property market and revitalizing town’s central core. In April 2021, metropolis council permitted Calgary’s Greater Downtown Plan: Roadmap to Reinvention. Acting on a key pillar of the decade-long program, town flagged its intention to eliminate 557,420 sq. metres of unused workplace area—and introduced it might offer grants to builders keen to tackle the problem of reworking that area into one thing new. Residential-conversion initiatives—the main target of that preliminary section—had been eligible for grants of $75 per sq. foot, as much as $15 million.
Olshevsky eagerly utilized as a part of the primary cohort, explaining the complete extent of what he wished to do with the constructing—create family-friendly models with trendy facilities and a floor flooring devoted to retail—in his utility. His proposal for 909 fifth Ave. SW was permitted just a few months later. Dubbed “The Cornerstone,” it obtained an funding of $7.8 million in municipal funds to transform roughly 9,662 sq. metres. The challenge broke floor in late 2022 and is on schedule to be accomplished by January.
But for Olshevsky, it was just the start. The 36-year-old developer, who immigrated to Calgary from Ukraine at 13 and grew up within the downtown space, had been working in development since he was 16, when he began out putting in wooden flooring. He went on to broaden his expertise as a contractor and finally gravitated towards conversions, partly as a result of he realized he might seize on the worth of initiatives that different individuals didn’t wish to tackle. “We understood that even though these buildings were neglected, it was much better to bring them back to the community than leave them boarded up,” says Olshevsky.
Related: This Former Convent in Nova Scotia Is Now a Vibrant Arts Hub
The Cornerstone challenge grew to become, properly, the cornerstone of Peoplefirst Developments—a subsidiary of Astra Real Estate Group—the place, as managing director, Olshevsky hinges his key technique on office-residential conversions. In February, Peoplefirst acquired the Petro-Fina Building, a mid-century midrise at 736 eighth Ave. SW, one block east and about 4 blocks south of The Cornerstone. Shortly thereafter, Olshevsky added Place 800—a 17-storey behemoth on sixth Ave. SW, smack dab in the course of the 2 different properties—to his portfolio. “I was like, we have to secure our place. Otherwise, all the big boys—the larger and more established development firms—will come in and scoop up all these projects.” Peoplefirst at the moment has greater than 46,450 sq. metres beneath conversion, all within the downtown core.
This previous April, the City of Calgary unveiled the 5 office-residential conversions (by 5 completely different builders, together with Peoplefirst, whose Petro-Fina challenge is on the docket) permitted beneath Phase Two of the Greater Downtown Plan, bringing the grand whole of works in progress to 10 for the reason that program was rolled out in 2021. As Mayor Jyoti Gondek famous on the press convention, the place she introduced the most recent slate of initiatives, these transformations will eliminate tens of millions of sq. metres of at the moment unused workplace area and contribute greater than 1,200 models to Calgary’s housing provide.
A report printed in May pegged Calgary’s inhabitants at 1,389,000—a rise of about three per cent in comparison with the earlier yr, marking the best enhance on document. This pattern, which displays latest federal initiatives to encourage migration to Alberta, is according to what’s occurring throughout the entire nation, which noticed the very best fee of first-quarter progress since 1972—0.7 per cent, or almost 300,000 individuals. And that spike constructed on one other milestone: The yr 2022 marked the primary 12-month interval in Canadian historical past when the inhabitants grew by greater than 1 million individuals. Statistics Canada estimates that the nation might be house to 45.5 million individuals by 2040 and 52.1 million individuals by 2060, and all these individuals will want locations to dwell—particularly, locations that they will afford.
“I thought that if this building sat here like this for almost 10 years, how many other commercial buildings in Calgary were in the same condition?”
For a metropolis—or province, or nation— to thrive, it wants a thriving industrial sector. And for a business to thrive, it wants to draw in-demand expertise. If a possible candidate can’t discover an inexpensive place to dwell within the basic neighborhood of a possible job, it’s unlikely they’re going to relocate to simply accept that job. As properly, housing shortages and sky-high rents can have a domino impact on industrial actual property, which may immediate firms to actually take their business elsewhere. In Calgary, the common lease for a one-bedroom condo was hovering round $1,825 in September 2023—a soar of 26 per cent yr over yr. Based on the City of Calgary’s 2023 Housing Needs Assessment, a resident would want to make a mean of $84,000 a yr to maintain tempo with present market rents—a determine that has elevated outrageously from 2022, when a mean wage of $67,000 was ample.
At first look, it’s onerous to not suppose like Olshevsky—certainly these initiatives are a no brainer. If staff are fleeing downtown cores like people fleeing a zombie invasion—and, on the identical time, cities throughout the nation are fighting an absence of ample housing to satisfy the wants of their evolving populations—then it follows that remodeling any and each deserted workplace tower into residential models is successfully killing two birds with one stone. The trick, after all, is that it’s not fairly so simple as that tidy narrative would lead you to consider. For starters, buildings are wildly different. Cities are wildly different—geographically, bureaucratically, economically, demographically. And if the previous 4 years have taught us something, it’s {that a} technique that doesn’t account for variability is doomed to fail.
As pilot initiatives go, Calgary’s Greater Downtown Plan has been a terrific success, not less than when it comes to program uptake, red-tape discount and total momentum associated to revitalization. Earlier this yr, The Washington Post proposed that the municipality ought to be a mannequin for North American cities trying to reinvigorate their central cores. But in relation to downtown wastelands, Calgary is—and was—in a category of its personal. While different locations—from Washington, D.C., to Montreal—had been left reeling when their financial centres had been devastated by the results of the pandemic, Calgary’s points began lengthy earlier than Covid. The present state of town’s core could be traced again almost a decade, to round 2014 or 2015, when a significant recession within the oil and gasoline sector was a catalyst for a gradual, regular decline.
Downtown Calgary was successfully developed on the behest of the oil and gasoline firms—reliant on the province’s seemingly unassailable pure assets—which started establishing their headquarters within the city core within the late Nineteen Forties and early Nineteen Fifties. For years, these firms—and the ancillary-use firms orbiting them—stored downtown bustling. While there have been downturns previous to the 2014 recession, the lulls had been at all times shorter and fewer extreme. After an enormous growth within the Nineteen Seventies, as an example, overzealous enlargement and a world recession resulted in an early-’80s bust, however ever-increasing worldwide calls for for fossil fuels meant issues had been again on monitor by the tip of the last decade. But in 2014, when oil costs plummeted as a consequence of unprecedented international provide progress, there was no bouncing again. By March 2016, about 100,000 jobs within the oil patch had been lower. In flip, there was a mass exodus from Calgary’s core: Between 2015 and 2021, the world misplaced roughly one-third of its tenants.
This was the disaster offered to metropolis council again in 2019, when Natalie Marchut, supervisor of improvement and technique in Calgary’s Downtown Strategy unit, and her colleagues started growing their revitalization plan. They had been dealing with a number of points that cropped up in a domino impact: The glut of underused workplace buildings within the downtown core brought on property values within the space to drop, which, in flip, led to a have to redistribute taxes to different non-residential properties. The consequence was a ghost city that was created by a corporate-centric monoculture. Even if there had been a surplus of housing accessible within the core, it might be onerous for anybody to think about themselves dwelling there.
“Year over year, we were not seeing any plans from building owners to do anything different—the buildings were just sitting vacant,” says Marchut. “In early 2022, we were sitting at about 34 per cent vacancy just in the downtown area, which equated to about 1.3 million square metres of unused space.” (In the second quarter of 2023, downtown Calgary’s emptiness fee was 31.5 per cent. For comparability, the speed in Vancouver was 11.5 per cent at the moment, whereas Toronto’s was almost 16 per cent.) Covid could not have brought on the issue, but it surely compounded it. “Property values across the city dropped by $16 billion, collectively,” Marchut says. “If you do the math on how that affects tax revenues, it’s significant.”
By the time Marchut and her colleagues launched this system, in September 2021, they’d decided that one of the best ways to sort out the revitalization was to make the method as easy and seamless as doable. The solely necessities positioned on Phase One proposals—like Peoplefirst’s Cornerstone—had been that the initiatives wanted to be a) residential conversions, b) of workplace buildings and c) within the downtown core. The no-strings strategy introduced forth debate. “We had internal folks asking: Could you have a climate requirement? Could you have an affordable-housing requirement?” says Marchut. “Those things are super important, but we intentionally kept it really simple because we were laser-focused on addressing the vacancy crisis.”
Their technique paid off. Marchut and her colleagues had anticipated perhaps 5 candidates within the preliminary spherical—they obtained 13 purposes, principally from conventional builders. The uptake of that preliminary spherical of initiatives inspired them so as to add circumstances for Phase Two candidates, resembling facilities at floor degree. There are additionally add-on incentives, just like the Downtown Retrofit Challenge, a competition-style grant—open to initiatives permitted by means of the Incentive Program—of as much as $1.2 million that was designed to assist offset prices associated to emission reductions and climate-resilience measures.
When the Downtown Strategy unit was hashing out the phrases of the Incentive Program, they landed on $75 per sq. foot, which, based mostly on an evaluation of common conversion-construction prices at the moment, was meant to cowl roughly 25 to 30 per cent of the whole price range. And for the preliminary spherical of initiatives, Marchut says, they had been roughly bang on. But since then, as a consequence of inflation, rates of interest and different market elements, the grant has lined proportionally lower than it did in Phase One; in response, she and her colleagues are within the strategy of reviewing the charges. “It’s a fine balance of offering enough that people will come to the table while not offering so much that the city is spending too much money.” In different phrases, it’s about contemplating always evolving elements, like housing costs, to make sure that these initiatives stay viable.
That steadiness is essential to creating positive that builders are keen to tackle the chance of conversions—unexpected prices could also be an excessive amount of of a deterrent in any other case. One of the most important challenges, Olshevsky says, is that conversion initiatives don’t adhere to a standard order of operations. That’s as a result of you’ll be able to’t at all times predict what these steps might be. With an current construction, there are duties which can be usually solely found when you begin the work. “It’s like when you buy a house, and then you realize they did DIY ductwork and everything is venting into the walls, and all of a sudden you’re screwed,” says Olshevsky.
“Year over year, we were not seeing any plans from building owners to do anything different—the buildings were just sitting vacant”
Building codes—their significance, their flexibility, their typically anachronistic nature—have been a central hurdle on this course of. Many of the buildings being transformed date again to a time when the codes had been very completely different. “Stairwell requirements have changed since the ’80s, but stairwells can’t be changed in a concrete-cast building,” Marchut says. “You can’t move or expand that element.” The ongoing dialog is the place to search out steadiness: How a lot can a regulation be relaxed? If a constructing exists—and has been occupied by workplace staff—is it honest to only make an exception? “Each project is so unique that we deal with them on a case-by-case basis,” she says.
Olshevsky’s workforce of about 20 individuals additionally introduced a form of outside-the-box considering to their financing of the Cornerstone challenge. Peoplefirst obtained $7.8 million in municipal funds for the conversion, which had a proposed price range of $38 million. To assist cowl the remaining prices, it used the start-up Addy, a crowdfunding platform that turns people into actual property micro-investors. Within two weeks of launching the marketing campaign, Addy hit its objective, elevating $500,000 from 800 contributors, every of whom kicked in, on common, $600. As Olshevsky explains, each a kind of micro-stakeholders receives the identical return on their contribution, percentage-wise, as, say, an accredited investor who ponies up $3 million.
The quantity of economic backing a challenge receives additionally informs how builders like Olshevsky would possibly design their conversions, like whether or not they are going to embrace bigger, extra family-friendly models. Technically, he says, it may be cheaper per sq. metre to construct an even bigger unit. But in relation to leasing out those self same models, as any savvy REIT will word, you’ll be able to’t lease them out for a similar value per sq. metre. “I can do a three-bedroom for $3,000 or three one-bedrooms for $1,600 apiece.” While this conundrum just isn’t particular to office-to-residential conversions, there’s a distinct form of strain concerned in determining facilitate the inclusion of extra numerous and extra inexpensive choices as a result of these initiatives are anchored in a broader dialogue round downtown revitalization. To create a metropolis core that’s vibrant and accessible to all residents, you need to make sure you’re creating areas that meet the wants of these residents.
Related: How to Create a Child-Friendly Workplace
Obviously, Calgary is removed from the one place the place the conversion of derelict industrial area is a hot-button challenge. Across the nation, builders are seizing on these websites with gusto—and with various levels of each institutional assist and success. Halifax-based Sidewalk Real Estate Development has utilized what it describes as a holistic strategy, braiding extra ineffable issues, resembling sustainability, historic significance and the will to catalyze “community pride,” into its seek for industrial property to overtake. Though the agency is lower than a decade previous, it’s had a hand in respiratory new life into downtown Dartmouth, the place its revamped low-rise buildings line the primary drag of Portland Street. Sidewalk’s newest Portland challenge entails changing the RBC Building—eight storeys of underused workplace area—into flats. As VP Joe Nickerson defined in a web based panel dialogue in May, the corporate’s success hinges, partly, on understanding every improvement as one part in a bigger ecosystem. “We’re long-term owners, and we’re heavily invested in the neighbourhoods.” For Sidewalk, this implies creating trendy flats that attraction to a youthful demographic, and so they’re layering these on prime of eating places and bars at avenue degree, which inspires foot visitors and attracts individuals from all around the metropolis. To fulfill a requirement of funding they’ve obtained from the province, they’re additionally incorporating a wholesome portion of inexpensive models—accessible for not less than 20 per cent beneath market lease.
In Winnipeg, Alston Properties has been taking over more and more formidable conversion initiatives for near a decade. The actual property and improvement firm’s portfolio consists of 433 Main St.—an austere Nineteen Seventies-era tower that previously housed Service Canada workplaces—the place 10 storeys containing 94 residential models at the moment are perched above 4 flooring of business exercise. In 2019, one in every of Alston’s initiatives, the Galpern Porter Building—a good-looking brick edifice that dates again to the early 1900s and had, at numerous instances, been occupied by a china wholesaler, a sweet firm and a nightclub— obtained a National Trust Award for “Transformative Projects.” The conversion comprises greater than 30 residential models inside a meticulously restored heritage facade. Company founder Bryce Alston has benefited from the assist of municipal and provincial grant applications, which, akin to Calgary’s Greater Downtown Plan, present incentives to builders who convert heritage buildings into rental properties.
“You can actually invest a few million and end up with a building that’s worth less than that”
Such collaborative efforts between completely different ranges of presidency are an important determinant of success on this context. In “The Case for Conversions,” the Canadian Urban Institute (CUI), a nationwide non-profit devoted to metropolis constructing, assessed six municipalities throughout the nation—Victoria, Regina, Winnipeg, Ottawa, Moncton and Halifax—to provide you with a set of circumstances that favour commercial-to-residential conversions. The report discovered that, together with constructing typology and placement, coverage and financial circumstances are the 2 most influential areas the place governments can play a task in growing the viability of conversion initiatives by means of measures like adaptive rules, extra versatile zoning and incentivization applications.
To be honest, even the best-laid and -incentivized plans don’t at all times bear fruit. In 2022, actual property dealer Chris Tammi purchased a mixed-use low-rise within the downtown core of Sudbury, Ont., with the purpose of turning the construction—previously the positioning of an insurance coverage firm—right into a multi-unit residential complicated balanced on main-floor industrial area. Although town had just lately bolstered its grant program, providing $20 per sq. foot or $20,000 per unit for office-to-residential conversions, Tammi’s expertise illustrates why subsidies alone aren’t sufficient. In this case, bringing the constructing as much as code would have concerned so many alterations that the overhaul wouldn’t repay. Factor in the price of web site remediations based mostly on environmental assessments (a priority in Sudbury, the place the spoils of heavy trade are widespread) and, as Geoff McCausland, a former metropolis councillor within the area who now works alongside Tammi, informed the CBC, “You can actually invest a few million and end up with a building that’s worth less than that.” It’s an vital reminder for would-be builders: Before you purchase, do your homework. And it’s an vital lesson for cities: Simply directing funds to the non-public sector with out contemplating the general panorama is insufficient if you’re attempting to resolve each a industrial actual property downside and a housing one.
For this motive, Jennifer Barrett, CUI’s managing director, says that conversion is just one piece of the puzzle—inexperienced areas, companies and providers are all wanted to create a vibrant neighbourhood. She’s in favour of plans that compel builders to optimize all ground-floor footage, taking area away from empty lobbies for retail or different makes use of, resembling baby care, cafés or artists’ studios, that animate the streetscape. “There’s always this complexity in an urban environment: How many regulatory strings can you pull to get a grocery store in the area, or a pharmacy or medical facility? Cities have gone through all sorts of regulatory challenges in trying to curate a main street or commercial core that has the right mix.” Daycare, for instance, could be operated by a personal firm, so a authorities can’t mandate that one open in a sure space. Likewise, inexperienced areas and playgrounds should be created over time as land and funding change into accessible.
In early 2021, it grew to become clear that the pandemic had dealt a devastating blow to just about each city centre throughout Canada: Workers deserted workplace towers; austerity, inflation and the extreme claustrophobia of being trapped at house prompted households to hunt out area and affordability within the suburbs and past. CUI ramped up its formidable challenge to jump-start the sluggish hearts of cities throughout the nation with a marketing campaign dubbed Bring Back Main Street (BBMS), a callback to a time when a metropolis’s major thoroughfare was equal components financial centre and neighborhood gathering place. The group enlisted the assistance of a cabal of specialists to develop a imaginative and prescient for not simply rebuilding but additionally reconceiving the central components of our municipalities. The questions that wanted to be answered had been deceptively easy however epic of their scope: What do we wish the longer term to appear to be? What do Canada’s cities want their downtowns to change into?
CUI decided that all downtowns are topic to a few doable futures: 1) full abandonment (the worst-case situation, akin to a zombie apocalypse—visions of which could be seen in Nova Scotia’s Cape Breton Regional Municipality, an space that’s riddled with condemned industrial areas, a few of which have been taken over by squatters); 2) more and more prohibitive prices, rendering the core accessible to solely the wealthiest; and three) a extra optimistic outlook, wherein concerted restoration efforts prioritize variety, creativity, flexibility and environmental and financial sustainability.
In working to realize this third possibility, Marchut notes, many cooks within the kitchen could also be the most effective factor. “I’ve been working for the city for 10 years, and I’ve never seen so much collaboration toward an outcome,” she says. For her, the most important shift affecting the way forward for Calgary’s core entails the collective engagement of civic companions, metropolis council, administration and trade. “We would not be on the track we’re on now if that hadn’t happened. Even many of the suburban councillors, whose constituents don’t live in this area, have come together to advocate because they see the importance of downtown for Calgary as a whole.”
Crucially, recruiting key stakeholders to form initiatives is a part of guaranteeing that the outcomes mirror essentially the most important wants—not just for these trying to dwell in future models but additionally when it comes to the broader necessities of a thriving metropolis. This would possibly embrace focused neighbourhood assessments to find out what components are lacking from a sure space. In Calgary, metropolis employees teamed up with the Urban Calgary Students Association, a bunch affiliated with the University of Calgary, final January as a part of an unconventional blue-sky session aimed toward soliciting younger individuals to assist reconceive the core. They would, in any case, change into the following wave of individuals coming into the workforce and, ideally, dwelling and dealing downtown. The challenge, referred to as Sketch Mob, invited these college students to a few downtown stretches in prime riverfront places—all coincidentally inside a stone’s throw of Peoplefirst’s conversions—the place they had been tasked with sketching concepts on enhance what they noticed. Findings included walkability—that’s, having a wide range of facilities, like grocery shops and leisure, inside a small radius—and entry to transit.
The Downtown Calgary Development Incentive Program has developed within the two years because it launched. The municipal program now consists of tiers of funding for non-residential initiatives—office-to-hotel conversions can obtain as much as $60 per sq. foot, whereas towers which can be remodeled into faculties and humanities centres are eligible for $50 per sq. foot in grants. Right now, enterprising people are discovering important new makes use of for areas which have gone uncared for. In the Calgary Tower Centre, a 24,387-square-metre skyscraper within the downtown core, an organization referred to as AgriPlay has rented out a complete flooring and remodeled it right into a vertical farm that produces all the things from greens to strawberries. In Alberta—the province with the very best fee of meals insecurity within the nation—the prospect of turning unused workplace area into de facto farmland could assist sort out a separate (however equally vital) problem in revitalizing the core.
Related: BMO’s New Toronto HQ Is Inside a Converted Department Store
For cities—and residents—all over the world, the pandemic catalyzed a Great Reset, a chance to re-evaluate the elements of on a regular basis life that had been now not related or efficient, with the hope of devising a brand new and higher approach ahead. What Calgary affords within the wake of its personal Great Reset is a imaginative and prescient of the place different struggling cities is perhaps 5 or 10 years from now. But even this plan is evolving in actual time. Growing consciousness round local weather points and skyrocketing prices of supplies are a part of the puzzle.
Olshevsky says that this isn’t a case the place “if you build it, they will come” can suffice. If these conversion initiatives are in the end going to achieve success, then they should change into commodities in excessive demand—in any other case, many builders aren’t going to really feel particularly compelled to tackle the potential dangers and unexpected prices. And for that to occur, the initiatives have to be anchored in areas the place potential residents can already think about themselves. When Olshevsky imagines a doable future, his thoughts goes to not Manhattan or to different North American centres however to the bustling cities in Europe and Latin America, the place cores are anchored in the concept that downtowns should not merely locations you go to work, hammer out a deal over lunch after which take the prepare house from. Transforming workplace towers is a begin, however vibrant cores are collective efforts—a mixture of coverage, funding, neighborhood session and capital initiatives. “Remove the barriers to creativity,” says Olshevsky, “and people will create things for others to come.”
